Rules

The selection
rule.

How peer ranks and full reviews become a decision. The weights, the tie rule and the version are published before intake, and a cohort keeps the version it started with.

How a decision is made

  1. At least ten peers rank each paper twice.

    Once for expected impact, once for interest in hearing a talk. At least ten distinct peers rank every eligible paper.

  2. About the top 30% become finalists.

    The cut uses the impact rank only. Finalists get full reviews from peers on other finalist teams.

  3. The two kinds of evidence are combined.

    The impact rank and the full-review evidence combine under one rule, published before intake opens.

  4. Selected papers are placed in a journal.

    Eligible finalists are ordered by the combined score and fill TenPeers Select first, then TenPeers Research. The decision names the journal.

  5. Every team gets a decision record.

    It shows the evidence the rule used, so a result can be checked against the rule.

There is no chair vote. Talk interest goes to event organizers and never feeds a publication decision.

The published rule

Decisions link to the version of the rule they used.

PartValue
Version2026-12-v1
Takes effectFrom the first cohort, December 2026
Weight of the full-review evidence60%
Weight of the impact rank40%
Tie ruleThe higher mean full-review assessment wins. If still tied, the better impact rank wins.
Eligible for publicationA finalist is eligible when its mean full-review assessment is at least "support" and no consequential error raised in review is left unanswered.
JournalsTenPeers Select takes the eligible finalists with the highest combined scores, up to 5% of the cohort's submissions. TenPeers Research takes the next eligible finalists, up to a further 10%.

The weights and the tie rule are fixed before intake opens and do not change during a cohort.

Version history

Version 2026-12-v1. From the first cohort, December 2026. Full-review evidence 60%, impact rank 40%. Tie rule: The higher mean full-review assessment wins. If still tied, the better impact rank wins. Eligibility: A finalist is eligible when its mean full-review assessment is at least "support" and no consequential error raised in review is left unanswered. Journals: TenPeers Select takes the eligible finalists with the highest combined scores, up to 5% of the cohort's submissions. TenPeers Research takes the next eligible finalists, up to a further 10%.

Each later version keeps its own section here, with the anchor #v<version>, so an older decision still links to the rule it used.

Conflicts

A peer is never assigned their own team's paper, a coauthor's paper, or a paper from someone at the same affiliation. If a peer still finds a conflict, they flag it on the ballot or the review, and an editor replaces that paper with another. The flag is recorded with the assignment.