# The selection rule.

How peer ranks and full reviews become a decision. The weights, the tie rule and the version are published before intake, and a cohort keeps the version it started with.

## How a decision is made

1. **At least ten peers rank each paper twice.** Once for expected impact, once for interest in hearing a talk. At least ten distinct peers rank every eligible paper.
2. **About the top 30% become finalists.** The cut uses the impact rank only. Finalists get full reviews from peers on other finalist teams.
3. **The two kinds of evidence are combined.** The impact rank and the full-review evidence combine under one rule, published before intake opens.
4. **Selected papers are placed in a journal.** Eligible finalists are ordered by the combined score and fill TenPeers Select first, then TenPeers Research. The decision names the journal.
5. **Every team gets a decision record.** It shows the evidence the rule used, so a result can be checked against the rule.

There is no chair vote. Talk interest goes to event organizers and never feeds a publication decision.

## The published rule

Decisions link to the version of the rule they used.

| Part | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Version | 2026-12-v1 |
| Takes effect | From the first cohort, December 2026 |
| Weight of the full-review evidence | 60% |
| Weight of the impact rank | 40% |
| Tie rule | The higher mean full-review assessment wins. If still tied, the better impact rank wins. |
| Eligible for publication | A finalist is eligible when its mean full-review assessment is at least "support" and no consequential error raised in review is left unanswered. |
| Journals | TenPeers Select takes the eligible finalists with the highest combined scores, up to 5% of the cohort's submissions. TenPeers Research takes the next eligible finalists, up to a further 10%. |

The weights and the tie rule are fixed before intake opens and do not change during a cohort.

## Version history

**Version 2026-12-v1.** From the first cohort, December 2026. Full-review evidence 60%, impact rank 40%. Tie rule: The higher mean full-review assessment wins. If still tied, the better impact rank wins. Eligibility: A finalist is eligible when its mean full-review assessment is at least "support" and no consequential error raised in review is left unanswered. Journals: TenPeers Select takes the eligible finalists with the highest combined scores, up to 5% of the cohort's submissions. TenPeers Research takes the next eligible finalists, up to a further 10%.

Each later version keeps its own section here, with the anchor `#v<version>`, so an older decision still links to the rule it used.

## Conflicts

A peer is never assigned their own team's paper, a coauthor's paper, or a paper from someone at the same affiliation. If a peer still finds a conflict, they flag it on the ballot or the review, and an editor replaces that paper with another. The flag is recorded with the assignment.

---
Source: https://tenpeers.com/rules/
